I would go for Cerise too, as I love her hat, outfit and hair! Apple comes up a close second, as her outfit is cute and I like her hair. Briar I like but she doesn't jump out at me - I'm not a hug fan of her hat. And hats count for a lot with me . I've been told (I think it was earlier in this thread actually) that Hat-tastic Maddie will come in a playset with Cedar, so I guess she would keep Maddie company. Looking forward to seeing proper pictures of them though, I much prefer seeing owner photos than just seeing the promo shots. The pictures I've seen of Hat-tastic Apple on Tumblr are fantastic. So do you collect all the Ever After High dolls or are you a selective collector like me?