I have a handy dandy spreadsheet with my trades on it. I decided not to pursue it since this person trades for their kids. But, I will definitely consider this if I am ever approached by this person again. I am going to pull the fake pin off my board so I have room for real pins. As far as the problem with your pin, I am having difficulty finding the issue you see. I keep looking at the photos. And, the one thing that keeps coming up is that one pin has a pin back and the other doesn't.