Men are such beasts
I say neither one is authentic. I compared them both to the one on pinpics and there are several subtle differences. Without getting too wordy, the left eyelid on the left one connects and shouldn’t, the arc on the left eyebrow appears off on both, the blue strap over the shoulder looks likes it connects to the collar instead of running alongside it (on both), and there appear to be only 5 eyelashes on the left eye of the left pin (compared to 6 on the pinpics one) and the eyelashes on the right one are indistinguishable. It’s tough to explain some of the other subtleties. The colors are very different, but that could be the camera used to take the pictures.
If one is a scrapper, I will happily take it off your hands :]