Should I return this pin or not?

Hey all,

I wanted to ask for an opinion regarding a recent eBay purchase. The picture straight from the eBay auction is listed below:




I thought it was really cool because I own the same pin but with a maroon ring around the outside and this one clearly looks green. So, I bought it and just received it today. And it looks like:



Now the issue for me is that I already have this pin, but the eBay post looked like a different pin. The eBay post (if you want to see it, search 170919455126 on eBay) says nothing about the color, green or maroon.

So what do you think I should do?

it doesn't even look like the same pin, did it come with the backing?

I think you should contact the seller and let them know. Most sellers are pretty reasonable about returns, especially in situations like this where the pin you received is obviously not the pin you thought you were buying.