Thanks, YoSoyAhPuch.
I am feeling much better today. Headaches ARE evil!
The pin I wanted was pin I wanted was
Pin 90199: WDW - Disney's Art of Animation Resort Logo Pin - Crush and Dory, which I don't think is rare or anything but I have been trying to get it at a good price for a while. There are a couple on ebay for low prices but they come from a seller that has some negative feedback for allegedly selling counterfeit pins and they mention that the pin "can be traded" in the description.
I will have to check out the Snipe thing. That sounds cool.