I've had a few troubles in the past, but never missing item luckily. Usually when I've contacted them by email they've done their best to help out - once the item wasn't as listed, so they immediately amended the listing on the site to be correct, offered me a refund if I wanted to return the item and when I decided to keep it, they still gave me a discount code. Another time I had a damaged pin and asked for a partial refund as it was LE and sold out so I knew I couldn't get a replacement. They insisted they do not do partial refunds but again, gave me a discount code.
I have to admit, I got my Up pin today and it has a black mark on Russell's leg, but as it is sold out and I now know their policy on not granting partial refunds on damaged items, I shan't bother complaining, I'm just hoping the person I got it for doesn't mind! My Frozen mugs came in the same order though and are perfect
.
They can be pants sometimes but you just have to perservere. I second what OlafOlaf said - contact using a private message on FB, they respond much more quickly to that than email.
Flaming Nora - do try the code again. One of the ones I got didn't work initially but did when I tried it a month later, it seems they take a while to activate. You may find it works now. If not, send them a message on FB.
As a side note, DisneyDevoted, I notice you say each time you wanted to sell one of the four your ordered to recoup your money. Do you mean to recoup the money spent on one pin? Or do you mean selling one pin to recover what you spent on all four?