Limited Edition 17" Collector Dolls Information
Matthewlondon
Active DPF Member
- Messages
- 1,306
- Location
- South Yorkshire UK
I would not say she is ugly but everyone is entitled to their own opinion. To me Alice has a classic look. Whereas Elsa has a more modern look, so it is like comparing apples and oranges. I do get a little disappointed when people undermine the beauty of Alice because she is so expensive and in most cases people try to find a reason to hate the item to justify them never being able to buy it, you would be surprised but this happens a lot especially since people have never been able to see the dolls in real life and like i say time and time again, these dolls are very different in person when compared against photos.
I definitely disagree about the Barbie look as her face mould is the same as Snow White, just because a doll has blonde hair it doesn't make her Barbie. Cinderella does look very Barbie and even Designer Aurora because of their newer look.
Also the Elsa LE doll is actually far from being movie accurate, same thing with Snow White. Her face is a lot thinner on the doll than it is in the movie, her doll is a lot paler (and in the Harrods set she has a purple hue to her skin tone like a lighter version of Ursula). Also her hair is way off.
That being said those are all minor things and personally I still think the doll is amazing even with it's obvious variations.
Elsa really was a hype doll whereas Snow White and Alice got reached those prices due to their appearance and the demand for them, if she really was not that amazing I don't think she would sell as well. Granted she has a lower LE size she is still one of the better LE dolls out there.
Personally I believe she is just overlooked because she is not a Princess, plus the 2010 movie Alice in Wonderland wasn't the best. I dunno I like to appreciate the dolls for how amazing they look as opposed to complaining about their flaws.
I have never seen Alice in person and I'm not a huge Alice in Wonderland fan so I shouldn't say she's ugly, she's just not my cup of tea based on pictures I have seen.
Regarding people putting a doll down to justify them never being able to afford this, I have seen this with Snow White, Elsa and Alice and it's quite annoying. I realise Alice shares the same face as Snow White but with the different paint job I I prefer Snow.
And yes Cinderella and Aurora have a slight barbie look but I can also see their character in the sculpt/paint job(aurora more so than Cinderella) were as with Alice I don't see either the movie or animated character I just see blue eyes, blonde hair and a generic looking face. That is why I thought she looked barbieish. The paint job on the sculpt transforms the doll to Snow White but with Alice I feel she looks generic. And I have also always disliked the super long hair and thought it would look better on a Aurora not Alice. Her dress is nice and detailed though and I do like that.
I understand different people like different dolls though. It's just personally both Wonderland dolls as well as Prince Eric are my least favourites of the line.
I do think Elsa is gorgeous though because by one look at her you know exactly who the doll is. And she is very detailed and beautiful.