Tinker Bell Dolls - Disney Store 10'' Classic vs Jakks Pacific 9'' The Pirate Fairy
Comparing two recently released Tinker Bell full sized dolls, that promote the upcoming Disney Fairies movie The Pirate Fairy. On the left is the 2014 Tinker Bell 10'' Flutter Wing Doll, part of the Disney Fairies Classic Doll Collection, that I purchased from my local Disney Store. On the right is the Disney Fairies The Pirate Fairy 9†Tink Doll, by Jakks Pacific. They have been fully deboxed, and are posed standing, supported by Kaiser doll stands (not included). Photographed in diffuse natural light.
Following the photos is my full comparative review of the two dolls.
2014 Tinker Bell Full Sized Dolls - Disney Store 10'' Classic vs Jakks Pacific 9'' The Pirate Fairy - Side By Side - Full Front View by
drj1828, on Flickr
2014 Tinker Bell Full Sized Dolls - Disney Store 10'' Classic vs Jakks Pacific 9'' The Pirate Fairy - Side By Side - Full Rear View by
drj1828, on Flickr
2014 Tinker Bell Full Sized Dolls - Disney Store 10'' Classic vs Jakks Pacific 9'' The Pirate Fairy - Side By Side - Portrait Front View by
drj1828, on Flickr
Comparative Review of Disney Store 2014 Classic vs Jakks Pacific The Pirate Fairy Tinker Bell Dolls
The Disney Store doll is an accurate depiction of the current Tinker Bell character in Disney's Disney Fairies movies, wearing her a version of her iconic strapless short green dress and green shoes with white pom-poms. She is listed as 10'' high and has flutter wings attached to the back of her body. Her outfit and wings are covered in green glitter.
The Jakks Pacific doll is a version of Tinker Bell wearing a Pirate outfit, consisting of a purple velvet jacket, jagged green skirt, knee high purple boots with white pom-poms. She also has a green headband and green belt. I don't know if she ever wears this outfit in the upcoming The Pirate Fairy movie, but it's a nice change from her usual outfit. Her face is much more similar to the animated Tinker Bell in original Peter Pan movie than it is to the character in the current movies. She is listed as 9'' high and has removable wings attached to the back of her dress. She has glitter in her skirt and on the trim of her jacket, but none on her wings.
Following is a feature by feature comparison of the two dolls.
Face: The Disney Tink has a larger, rounder face. Her eyes are smaller, less slanted, further apart and a brighter shade of blue. She is glancing to her left, but other than that, her face is completely symmetrical, making her appearance a little bland. The Jakks Tink is glancing to her right, and has a smirk on her lips, and wiggle in her eyebrows that make her face much more animated than the DS Tink. The Disney Tink has yellow eye shadow with nine short fine eyelashes over each eye; the Jakks Tink has four thicker eyelashes over each eye, and has silver and pink eyeshadow. The Disney Tink has a smaller nose and a open smile with thin dark pink lips. The Jakks Tink has fuller red lips in a sassy smirk. The Disney Tink has much paler skin, and less rouge on her cheeks. They both have pointy ears, but the Disney doll's ears are slightly larger.
Hair: They both have light blonde hair with Tink's trademark bun and front bangs. The Disney doll has slightly lighter hair. The Disney Tink has a lot of hair product in her front bangs, making them very stiff, whereas the Jakks Tink has little or none, so her bangs are very soft and pliable. They both have lots of hair product in their buns, to keep their shape, so they are fairly stiff. The Jakks has a green satin headband with a buckle on top. The Disney Tink has no hair accessories.
Outfit: The Disney doll has a one piece dress that is based on the iconic strapless short green dress worn by the animated character. The bodice is held up by clear plastic straps, and the skirt is made up of two layers of large textured leaves. Both the bodice and skirt are heavily covered in green glitter. The glitter does shed quite a bit, sticking to her face and body, but especially her rubber legs. Her shoes are her iconic green slippers with white pom-poms.
The Jakks doll has a Pirate inspired outfit that consists of a purple velvet jacket with glittering gold trim, a green plastic belt with a cameo of Tink and anchor emblems. The skirt simulates leaves with jagged edges on the light green solid cloth, with a tulle overskirt lightly covered in multi-colored glitter. She is wearing knee-high purple books made of hard plastic, with white pom-poms over the toes.
Wings: The Disney doll has larger wings, with a more intricate pattern that is covered in green glitter. They are made of smooth translucent hard but flexible plastic sheets. They are permanently glued to a hinged mechanism in her back. There is a spring loaded button that when pressed causes the wings to flap outward (away from the body), and when released causes the wings to rest on her back again.
The Jakks doll has wings that are both smaller and thinner, and are made of transparent smooth flexible plastic. Embedded in the plastic is a semi-transparent metallic layer that has holographic images of stars. The stars are of various shapes and sizes, and glow with different colors depending on the angle of the reflected light.
Body: The Disney doll is 10'' from the heel of her foot to the top of her head, and stands 10 1/4'' high wearing the included flat shoes on angled feet. The Jakks doll is 9 1/4'' from the heel of her foot to the top of her head, and stands 9 3/4'' high wearing included boots with platform heels. She has feet that are more severely angled, and are also stiffer (being hard plastic rather than rubbery plastic), so she winds up only 1/2'' shorter than the Disney doll in total height, rather than the 1'' implied by their listed heights. Although they are almost the same height, their body proportions and articulation are very different.
The Jakks doll has a much shorter and skinnier torso, narrower shoulders, shorter arms and smaller head. As I previously noted with the Zarina dolls, the Jakks doll can probably fit the Disney dress, but it will be a bit loose on her. Also she wont have wings unless a Velcro strip is sewn (or glued) to the back of her dress facing out, so the Jakks wings can be attached. The Jakks Zarina dress was much too small to fit on the Disney Zarina doll, but I will have to see if the same holds true for the Tinks.
They both have painted on light green panties, matching the colors of their skirts. The Disney doll's panties are a solid green, while the Jakks ones are decorated with a pattern of inscribed leaves.
I have described the articulation on the Jakks Disney Fairies dolls in great detail in my comparison between Disney Merida and Jakks Zarina. But here is a summary: The Jakks doll has ball jointed neck, shoulders, elbows, wrists, hips and knees. All the joints can both rotate and tilt, and have much more freedom of movement than the corresponding joints on the Disney doll. The Disney doll has swivel neck, ball jointed shoulders, elbows and hips, and internal hinge jointed knees on her rubber legs. Her wrists and ankles are at fixed angles. With her reduced articulation, the Disney doll is much less posable, but also looks more natural without all the exposed joints.
Availability and Cost: The Disney doll is sold exclusively by the Disney Store, both online and in stores, throughout the world. She is $14.95 US, or $10 each when two or more Classic dolls are bought at the same time. The Jakks doll is sold at Target and other retailers in the US, online and in stores. She is $16.99 US, and is promoted as a deluxe version of the Tinker Bell doll.
Summary: They are both very attractive and well made dolls. The Disney doll is an accurate depiction of the current Disney Fairies Tinker Bell animated character, wearing her iconic little green dress. Her relative lack of articulation makes her more natural looking. She has a pretty, joyful and sweetly innocent face. I consider the Flutter Wings to be more of a gimmick than a useful feature, but her wings are very pretty and match her outfit very well. The Jakks doll has a more attractive face, in my opinion, that also happens to have the appearance and attitude of the original animated Tinker Bell, whom I prefer over the current animated character. Her face has much more personality and looks more realistic than the Disney doll. Her outfit is pretty, but is not as well made as the Disney outfit, especially the skirt and the cheap looking belt, which is too much of one color. Her wings are also pretty, but I like the Disney ones better, even with the shedding glitter (which I think of as Pixie Dust). The more extensive articulation makes her much more posable than the Disney doll, but it also makes her less natural looking. The other thing is that the Disney doll is currently only $10, with the current promotion, versus $17 for the Jakks doll. I'm glad to have both dolls, and if I had to choose, I think I prefer the Jakks doll, which is the best looking Tinker Bell I've ever seen sold under the Jakks brand. But my all-time favorite Tinker Bell doll is the Disney Parks 11'' Tinker Bell, which is still available.
Purchase Details
Tinker Bell Disney Fairies Doll - 10''
US Disney Store
Released online 2014-01-27
Purchased in store 2014-01-31
$14.95 US
Classic Dolls $10 each when you buy 2 or more
Item No. 6070040900980P
Disney Fairies The Pirate Fairy 9†Tink Doll
Target Product Information and Images
Purchased online
Received 2014-02-11
$16.99 Online Price
Online Item #: 14761828