Well, here's my current one:
Like many of you, I could list the carousals, nouveau, Gomes, and Beast/Prince (which I bid on and lost at $75, right before it spiked and went crazy)...they're all on my Wants list, and have been since I created my page. But for something different, there's this beauty.
Never have seen it in person, even. It shows up on Ebay occasionally, but always just a little more than I want to pay for it.
And here's my success story:
This pin, as many of you old timers know, was scheduled for release on Disney Auctions right before it changed over to Disneyshopping.com. It, along with several other pins and sets, went missing, and were never released. In 2006/7, I decided to become a Jessica completionist (really, just a horrible decision, I had no idea the rarity of some of those pins at the time).
So at one of the pin events, one of the auction lots (or was it a grand prize winner prize?) had the AP set of this pin, making this unreleased pin suddenly out in the world as LE 3.
I lamented the fact that I would never, ever have this pin, and it was going to bother me forever.
Then, the impossible! One morning in 2008, all the "missing" pins were dumped on disneyshopping.com with no warning. It was very weird, because it was the middle of the week, when pins were usually released on Sunday evenings. Excited and scared, I went to the site, but alas, they were sold out. After a quick round of crying and cursing, I sucked it up and got on eBay and paid $99, knowing it would never sink below that again.
And that's the story of the impossible Jessica pin that became possible- and something that I hope will happen with the costumed Tinks that were never released.