Pixar 24-Feature Film Challenge!!! Thanks For Playing ~ Now In Theatres: Lightyear!!!
firechief18
Super Active DPF Member
- Messages
- 1,996
- Location
- Thurmont, MD
Luca
1. Overall impression of the film?Honestly…I was very disappointed in this movie. There wasn’t a single element in it that wasn’t borrowed from another Disney or Pixar movie. A reference here and there, or “Easter eggs” are one thing, but to sock the entire thing on a mish-mash of other storylines just doesn’t work. The cobbled together elements lack the cohesion of a good story.
The first correlation is to The Little Mermaid. Luca is obsessed with the surface and the “land monsters,” and yet knows that merfolk like himself can change to look human. He also collects and hides items that he finds from the surface. Just like Ariel, he has no idea what they do, only that they are from the surface. Luca’s mom, Daniela is the taskmaster, disciplinarian, and ruler of the household – totally freaking out with Luca on the land. She’s not that far off from King Triton.
Pinocchio is the second obvious connection. Alberto is Lampwick, hands down. Although he lives by himself, (unlike the Stupid Boys), he has no rules, does what he likes, and pushes Luca to be disobedient and reckless. He may not smoke or drink, but I still half-expected to see Luca sprout donkey’s ears and start braying.
Alberto also shows ties to Peter Pan. He’s basically an abandoned child, thus making him a Lost Boy. There isn’t much difference between the Stupid Boys and the Lost Boys in reality. They are both groups of children in desperate need of adult supervision and guidance. Where Alberto falls, in there, is toward the end where he admits his father went away and never came back. Like a lost boy, he wants a home, a parent to love him. That is a defining factor when he decides to stay with Massimo at the end.
The boys give a short nod to The Lion King. When Luca and Alberto decide to go to the mainland from the island, their frolicking freedom is reminiscent of the “I Just Can’t Wait to be King” sequence.
There is even a brief nod to Mulan in there. Luca’s grandmother, and Grandma Fa both are okay with covering for their grandchildren. When Luca is late coming home, and has no excuse Grandma Paguro LIES to cover for him. Grandma Fa points Mulan in the direction of the courtyard wall to see the emperor’s courier. Not a lie in that case, but certainly a breach of protocol in that household.
Then of course, there’s Ratatouille. When I see the story’s baddie, Ercole Viscotti; hear him speak, and watch his behavior, all I see is Chef Skinner. He is supposed to be Italian, but all I can see is that arrogant Frenchman. No one wants to stand up to him. They are afraid of him and what his two thugs will do.
Snow White’s huntsman is even portrayed. When the boys are revealed in the end to be sea monsters, Portorosso’s master hunter is expected to slay them. But just like the huntsman, Massimo cannot bring himself to do it. Where Snow White’s huntsman sends her running into the woods, Massimo simply defends the boys and the locals back down.
There is even a Simpsons’ moment. When Daniela gets all bent out of shape over the upcoming crab show season, she mentions a competitor who can squeal like a dolphin. When she does her mock imitation of that call the animation is reminiscent of the TV cartoon style found in The Simpsons.
And, it’s all a la Star Wars, Episode IV, A New Hope. When Luca’s mother decides he needs to be sent to the depths with Uncle Ugo for “one or two seasons,” it’s just like Uncle Owen telling Luke he cannot go to the academy, just for “one more season.”
Finally, the storyline is mediocre at best, if it’s even that good. Luca’s sudden daydreams are not really necessary to the story. They don’t connect to create a purpose, other than to lengthen the time of the cartoon. There were a few funny moments (such as Luca spitting his water on Alberto, or the antics of Massimo’s all-knowing cat – Machiavelli) but they were too few, and far between to salvage the movie. As I stated in the beginning of this rant - trying to mish-mash the best of other stories – intended or not, just doesn’t work.
5. Choose one specific symbol in the film to analyze.
The Vespa Scooter – Really? An entire story based on two kids wanting an ugly scooter. If the movie was funnier and more tongue-in-cheek…maybe it would have worked. The scooter, be it new, used, homemade, or dilapidated is the singular focus of Luca and Alberto. I will give them credit for working together toward that goal. In that, they didn’t waver. They race to win the money to get it, and succeed. But then Alberto does something totally unexpected. He did learn that there is more to life than things. He sells the scooter to pay for a train ticket for Luca to go with Giulia to school. And he had worked everything out with Luca’s parents. They had intended to get the scooter so they could see the world. They are going to do just that, but not in the ways they had imagined.
6. Choose a single line of dialogue that you find to be the most significant/impactful line in the film and why.
“Sea monster!” – Luca
Betrayal? From the self-proclaimed “good kid?” That is what happened when Alberto (in a fit of jealousy) shows Giulia what he and Luca really are. It backfired. Alberto thought he was forcing Luca to choose him by running off Giulia with the revelation. Horrified at losing his new friend Luca outs him, calling him a sea monster. What is most disturbing about this is that it doesn’t fit with the personality you have come to know as Luca. To betray a friend, for something is more in Alberto’s personality. It feels like the writers forced a change to make it fit the narrative, instead of following the narrative to its more natural pathway.
9. What is the iconic shot of the film? What single frame of animation do you find to be the most memorable and why?
Machiavelli sees everything! He knows something isn’t on the up and up. This is when we know that the cat will be causing shenanigans! There is a bit of humor here. Let the games begin!
10. What single pin do you think best represents this film for you? Why?
Pin FAC/SKU# 465054544502 (only number I could find, Could not find in PinPics and pintradingdb was not responding)
This cat is the best character in the movie. Without uttering a word, he conveys his dislike, distrust, and disapproval of Luca and Alberto. A cat knows a fish when he smells one…this leads to some funny scenes (the only ones worth seeing in the film.) If you can find Machiavelli without the rest of that hideous pin set – that’s who you want.