Limited Edition 17" Collector Dolls Information
I do think the coffin boxes suit them well. It's just that when dolls are part of the same line it's nice to have something that ties them all together (it doesn't necessarily have to be the boxes). I'm glad you have the dolls and like them. I will admit that I am a perfectionist and am very hard to please as a result. I just couldn't justify spending $200 on dolls with which I am not completely happy. I tend to expect more for TLM and NBC merchandise because they are my two favorite Disney movies and attention to detail is very important to me.
That is a fair point and I can understand people having their own personal expectations but I just always thought it a little harsh when Disney releases a doll and it is immediately criticized and put down due to it not meeting ones expectations. I think the fact that Disney just makes these dolls are amazing and let's face it no matter what there will always be disappointment because Disney cannot please everyone as everyone has different wants and preferences.
I too am a perfectionist and I believe most people are but in their own different way with each having a different perception of perfection, for some it may come down to the likeness of their favorite character to the actual animation, for others it may be having a complete collection. So I can understand why you would have been disappointed in the NBC line, I just think if you actually had a look at the item in person as photos generally don't do the dolls justice you will be amazed at how detailed and amazing they look. But hey each to their own, you have your reasons to not like them and I have my reasons to love them.
It is interesting that you mention that you would want something that ties them all together but to be honest apart from the fact that they are limited edition and have COAs I don't see how else you could tie the entire set together. I just see it as different lines of LE dolls, you have the princess or heirloom line (generally limited to 5000 with the villains having darker colored boxes and an LE of just 1500). then another line based on movies and other disney characters with varying edition sizes and varying boxes) and it is because of this distinction that I believe there is currently a consistency between the different lines.
Anyway there are just a few more weeks before they release the preorder for Ariel and I cannot wait as I will be getting one as soon as I can!