Thanks all! I do my best to lay it all out in terms of how I really feel about the dolls, both good and "what could be better." 😉 Now if only there were a way to make a career out of that...! hahaha...
Story, I also like that aspects of OUAT subtley leak out into this collection in the sense that they both are taking these iconic characters and fitting them into a more modern form. One does wonder how much Lana Parilla's Regina did influence the final version of Designer Queen Grimhilde, because I totally see her in this doll. 🙂 Not a bad legacy at all! I wonder if she is going to get one of these for herself? I still think I would like to see the Designer Maleficent doll's hair styled the same way they styled Kristin Bauer van Straten's hair in OUAT (but not blonde).
Alex555, it was very nerve-wracking to go through the random name selection process. I don't want to do that again. Hmmmm... My rankings for the dolls have been fluctuating a lot recently. Starting with the design sketches only, I ranked them: Cruella de Vil, The Queen of Hearts, Mother Gothel, Queen Grimhilde, Maleficent, and then Ursula. Ursula ended up last at that point, because I was really initially turned off by them making her skinny, but I did think her gown was good.
Pongo, thanks for sharing the Ashton Drake Queen Grimhilde and Snow White dolls! 🙂 I love their clothes, but unfortunately I am not too fond of their base dolls. From Ashton Drake, the Tiana dolls look good, but otherwise, the base dolls that they use are not so appealing to me for some reason. it's too bad they don't sell just the outfits.
With the promo pictures of the dolls thrown in, my ranking was initially: Cruella de Vil, Mother Gothel, The Queen of Hearts, Ursula/Queen Grimhilde (tied), and then Maleficent. I really hate what they did with Maleficent's hair horns, and it only got worse when it was revealed that they did a sloppy job of finishing up the hair ends with those hair nubs. So even though she has a good outfit for the most part and a very nice face, the hair ruined the overall look for me. The promo pictures of Queen Grimhilde put her near the bottom (all of the promo pictures highlight her "I smelled someting bad" expression). The color of Cruella de Vil's coat does not bother me at all, because her coat should be an off-white--all of Disney's Classic Cruella merchandise use a yellowish-cream color for her coat, and the Designer doll's coat matches that. I also mentally justify the "yellowing" as a consequence of all of her smoking!
After seeing the dolls in person, my current ranking is: Cruella De Vil, Mother Gothel/Queen Grimhilde (tied), Ursula, and then The Queen of Hearts/Maleficent (tied). As you can see, things have changed a bit. Queen Grimhilde moved up, as did Ursula. The Queen of Hearts moved way down on the list, despite having one of the prettier designs. Having seen the Designer Ursula doll in person, I got past her "skinny-ness" and weighed in on her gown, face, and styling. They are all very much Ursula. I actually envision her now at the point in the film when she is transforming into her Vanessa form, it's only a split second in the film, but it works for me. The Queen of Hearts fell in my rankings for three reasons: the execution and fit of her gown (it looks too bulky on her), the insistence that they give her those heart-shaped painted lips, and the spaced out look in her eyes. The doll just does not live up to the design sketch. I think there are two problem areas for the gown: 1) the tulle collar should have been a more streamlined collar made with gossamer-thin white lace ruffles, and 2) the layers of ruffles of the skirt should not have started so high up near the waistline of the skirt so that the red velvet side panels could lay flatter on her hips. Red velvet layered over stiff ruffles makes for a very bulky look. Sadly, for me, she is the "Designer Jasmine" of the collection: she had so much potential with the design sketch, but the execution of the actual doll failed her.
I will give my final rankings when I photograph and review each one in October. 🙂