I totally agree that it was fair to offer the poster to people who'd placed an order previously. I guess what I am trying to get at -- if someone ordered the album/poster deal on say Monday or Tuesday for the first time and got a confirmation for their order, and then someone who placed an earlier order waited until Wednesday to say they'd take a poster-- well, the poster shouldn't be taken away from the person who ordered Mon/Tues to give to the other person who waited until Wed to respond, regardless of whether they ordered the album earlier. (If that makes any sense!)
I thought that's what you meant when you said that those who ordered earlier got priority over the posters. Sorry if I misunderstood.
If the emails were sent out on that Monday morning then whoever ordered the albums previously would have had a chance to get their poster orders in before they went on sale to everyone else. The system should have kept track of all the orders, so it seems a poor excuse to say they over sold them. Even if that did happen, it is pretty late in the game to be informing people, if you ask me.
Polaris, when was your card charged? You said you weren't sure if it was for the record or not --is the charge from MyPlay direct or Disney?