This was me, too, especially about Lady Tremaine. She looked really nice in her stock photo but in person I was so unimpressed. It's the exact opposite with Disney Store blue Cinderella for me. In the stock photo she looked blah, but in real life, I just can't get over her adorable blue poof of a cupcake dress, which is how many layers? Like 4 at least. I think it's amazing, and in fact all the Disney Store film collection outfits are amazing. With so many pin pals posting positive things about the Mattel dolls, I had such high expectations but they just didn't match the quality (e.g., godmother dress, that 90s barbie hologram sheen material, vs. the disneystore regal edwardian ice blue gown).
I wonder if people were basing their opinions on the stock photos? And/or thrown off by the serious expressions. But seriously, the quality of the clothes on the DS film collection are divine, I'm not surprised Mattel was not able to match it.